*SET-U

GRAPH-WIDE SEARCH

MEASURE THE GRAPH ↗

NOT JUST A DICTIONARY LOOKUP

6 EVIDENCE COLLECTIONS

SEARCH
THE GRAPH.

Find a modern word—or search sideways through reconstructed roots, historical forms, meanings, languages, scholars, sources, claims, disputes, and witnesses.

35RESULTS RETURNED
2WORD DOSSIERS
4HISTORICAL NODES
12SOURCES
16CLAIMS
1WITNESSES
01

MODERN ENTRY POINTS

WORD DOSSIERS

2
02

ATTESTED / RECONSTRUCTED / BOUNDARY

HISTORICAL FORMS

4
03

WHERE INTERPRETATION IS TESTED

CLAIMS & DISPUTES

16

SCHOLARLY DISPUTES / 12

openprobableexact word

Did French borrow étymon through Latin or directly from Greek?

CNRTL names Latin etymon as the immediate donor; the Académie calls the French word a learned borrowing from Greek. The graph preserves the Latin route as probable, not certain.

resolvedestablishedexact word

Must an etymon be the deepest reconstructable root?

No. Merriam-Webster defines it as an earlier same-language or ancestral form, a foreign loan source, or a word or morpheme used in composition or derivation.

resolvedestablishedexact word

Are etyma and etymons both permitted plurals?

Yes. Merriam-Webster records etyma and etymons, with etyma preserving the learned Greek-style plural.

resolvedestablishedexact word

Must a French étymon be directly attested?

No. Both CNRTL and the Académie explicitly define the explanatory form as attested or reconstructed/hypothetical.

openprobableposition text

Does the English record begin in the 13th or 14th century?

The reviewed reports differ. Etymonline gives an early-thirteenth-century algorism; Merriam-Webster gives a fourteenth-century first-known-use horizon.

openprobableposition text

Did English algorism arrive through French or directly from Medieval Latin?

The sources preserve both channels. Merriam-Webster names Middle French and Medieval Latin; Etymonline emphasizes Old French from Medieval Latin.

openprobableposition text

Does the English record begin in the 13th or 15th century?

The reviewed source reports differ. Etymonline gives mid-thirteenth-century arsmetike; Merriam-Webster gives a fifteenth-century first-known-use horizon.

openproposedposition text

Is the deepest counting root *h₂rei- or *erei-dhmo- from *re-?

The references use different levels and notations: Merriam-Webster derives the Greek base through *h₂rei-, while Etymonline prints an expanded *erei-dhmo- formation tied to *re-.

openestablishedposition text

Was emoticon first used in 1987 or only by 1992?

Merriam-Webster reports first known use in 1987; Etymonline reports the word by January 1992 and quotes an August 1992 explanation.

openboundaryposition text

Can icon be securely reconstructed beyond Greek eikōn?

Not from the reviewed evidence. Merriam-Webster calls the proposed deeper base uncertain and a Lithuanian comparison doubtful; Etymonline likewise stops at uncertain Greek prehistory.

openprobableposition text

Was emotion first used in the 1570s or exactly 1579?

Etymonline gives the decade; Merriam-Webster gives 1579. These are compatible levels of precision, not proof of one first utterance.

openproposedposition text

Can the movement family be pushed securely beyond *meue-?

Not from the reviewed evidence. Etymonline publishes *meue- for the movement root, but this dossier does not promote an older form without specialist comparative review.

CONTRARIAN TRUTHS / 4

RANK 81GRADE Aexact ranked word

The etymon is not always the root of the root.

In technical use an etymon may be an earlier form, a foreign loan source, or a derivational word or morpheme—not necessarily the deepest reachable ancestor.

RANK 50GRADE Aranked reveal

The hostile adjective may belong to whet and threat, not hate—and its starred lemma still has a nominative.

Köbler's Old Saxon entry reports five written readings at three Heliand loci, including nominative hotie, huotia, and huoti, yet heads the entry hōti*. The asterisk therefore cannot be explained away as “no nominative survives.” More radically, the sources split at the root. UT groups hōti with hatōn and heti under the inherited hate etymon k̑ād-. Köbler's same entry cross-references hatōn but reconstructs a different *hwōtja- adjective beside *hwōtō “threat” and Pokorny's *kʷē̆d- / *kʷō̆d- family of boring, pricking, sharpening, whetting, and inciting. Munich hotie and hotean are directly visible in contexts of hostile minds and hostile intent; Cotton huotia, huotian, and huoti remain source-reported. The unveiling is not “hostility secretly means sharpened hate.” It is that rigorous etymology sometimes reveals two irreconcilable maps where a flat dictionary would print one arrow.

RANK 84GRADE Aranked reveal

Even the source-form can wear an asterisk.

French lexicography defines an étymon as attested or reconstructed/hypothetical. The unit used to explain a word’s history is not automatically a surviving word.

RANK 87GRADE Aranked reveal

The verb came before the science label.

Etymologize is reported from 1532 or the 1530s, while Etymonline dates etymology in the modern “science of linguistic analysis” sense to the 1640s.

04

BOOKS / DICTIONARIES / ARTICLES / DATABASES

SOURCES

12
historical dictionary15 CLAIM LINKS

Emotion — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary10 CLAIM LINKS

Icon — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary9 CLAIM LINKS

Etymologize — Online Etymology Dictionary

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary8 CLAIM LINKS

Arithmetic — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary8 CLAIM LINKS

Dialogue — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary8 CLAIM LINKS

Legislation — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary8 CLAIM LINKS

Prologue — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary7 CLAIM LINKS

Etymologist — Online Etymology Dictionary

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary6 CLAIM LINKS

-ist — Online Etymology Dictionary

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary6 CLAIM LINKS

Algorism — Origin and history

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary5 CLAIM LINKS

-al — Online Etymology Dictionary

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
historical dictionary5 CLAIM LINKS

-ize — Online Etymology Dictionary

Douglas Harper / 2026

citation-key prefixAUDIT EVERY USE ↗
05

FIRST USES & HISTORICAL OBJECTS

ATTESTATION WITNESSES

1
06

SEARCH IS DISCOVERY, NOT PROOF

EVERY RESULT OPENS A PERMANENT EVIDENCE RECORD.

Matching text only locates a record. It does not raise confidence, settle a dispute, establish cognacy, or turn a source report into direct inspection. Follow the result into its citations and editorial limits.