PERMANENT SOURCE RECORD
ALL SOURCES ↗BIBLIOGRAPHIC IDENTITYzieme-2008-shaman
SOURCE
RECORD.
One work. Every claim that depends on it. No citation without a consequence you can inspect.
5 PUBLIC LINKS INTO THE GRAPH.
This count excludes duplicate dossier-path citations. Open the claims below to see exactly how the source is used.
scholarly articlezieme-2008-shaman
A Note on the Word “Shaman” in Old Turkic
- AUTHOR / EDITOR
- Peter Zieme
- YEAR
- 2008
- PUBLISHER
- Shaman · International Society for Academic Research on Shamanism
- DOI
- Not recorded
- SOURCE TYPE
- scholarly article
- EXTERNAL RECORD
- OPEN ORIGINAL ↗
011
CONTRARIAN TRUTH CLAIMS
RANKED REVEALS THAT CITE THIS SOURCE
RANK 11GRADE Acontext
It was never humanity’s universal ancient name for spiritual practitioners.
English globalized a specific Evenki term through European scholarship and applied it to many unrelated traditions.
šamān
šamān → shaman
pp. 137–139 — deeper etymology disputedPrevents overclaiming the word’s ancestry.
shaman dossier ↗truth record ↗89UNVEILING
021
SCHOLARLY DISAGREEMENT
DISPUTE POSITIONS THAT CITE THIS SOURCE
opensupportsproposed
Does Evenki šamān securely descend from Sanskrit śramaṇa?
The resemblance and Central Asian transmission routes have motivated a hypothesis, but direct evidence connecting the Buddhist term to the Evenki word remains insufficient.
pp. 137–139 — three theories and direct-evidence gapDocuments the unresolved deeper-origin debate.
032
CANONICAL RELATIONSHIP CLAIMS
EDGES THAT CITE THIS SOURCE
EDGE 341supportsboundary
šamān → UNKNOWN
Evenki → Beyond secure reconstruction · knowledge boundary
- SOUND
- Competing Tungusic-internal and Buddhist Central Asian ancestry theories prevent a secure deeper promotion.
- MEANING
- The path stops at Evenki while the wider-origin debate remains visible.
- SCHOLAR / EDITOR
- SET-U editorial boundary · Peter Zieme
pp. 137–139 — competing theories and missing direct evidenceExplains why the Sanskrit or Central Asian comparison is not a secure promoted ancestor.
EDGE 342challengesspeculative
šamān → śramaṇa
Evenki → Sanskrit · proposed borrowing
- SOUND
- A line of argument compares Evenki šamān with Sanskrit śramaṇa through documented Central Asian reflexes, but the exact transmission and sound history into Tungusic are not demonstrated.
- MEANING
- A Buddhist ascetic or monk term is proposed as the source of a Tungusic ritual-specialist word.
- SCHOLAR / EDITOR
- Peter Zieme and prior scholars reviewed by him
pp. 137–139 — Sanskrit and Central Asian comparison; direct-evidence gapDocuments the comparative hypothesis while explicitly preserving the missing transmission evidence that keeps it speculative.
040
LEXICAL ATTESTATIONS
WITNESSES REPORTED BY THIS SOURCE
No lexical witness currently cites this source.
051
COMPARATIVE EVIDENCE
COGNATES, DESCENDANTS, AND RELATIVES
śramaṇa
Sanskritformal and historical comparison proposed through Central Asian Buddhist vocabulary; ancestry of Evenki remains disputed
060
GEOGRAPHIC AND TEMPORAL CLAIMS
JOURNEY STAGES THAT CITE THIS SOURCE
No journey-stage claim currently cites this source.
070
NON-GENEALOGICAL CONNECTIONS
HISTORICAL CONTEXT, KEPT SEPARATE
No non-genealogical context link currently cites this source.
081
WORD-FAMILY REUSE
DOSSIERS THAT DEPEND ON THIS SOURCE
1 entry-scoped citations map reviewed dossier paths onto the canonical claims above.